QAB Interview: A Discussion of the Beloved Family of Thomas Cromwell, 1st Earl of Essex with Teri Fitzgerald (Thomas Cromwell: Executed July 28, 1540)

James Frain as Thomas Cromwell
Credit: The Tudors, Showtime

________________________________

Today marks the anniversary of the 1540 tragic execution of Thomas Cromwell, 1st Earl of Essex. Accused of sacramentary heresy and a host of other clearly manipulated charges, Cromwell was felled by the influence of the conservative faction of King Henry VIII’s court, led by Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester and Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk. As contemporary chronicler Edward Hall teaches us…

“Many lamented but more rejoiced, and specially such as either had been religious men, or favoured religious persons; for they banqueted and triumphed together that night, many wishing that that day had been seven years before; and some fearing lest he should escape, although he were imprisoned, could not be merry. Others who knew nothing but truth by him both lamented him and heartily prayed for him. But this is true that of certain of the clergy he was detestably hated, & specially of such as had borne swynge [beaten hard], and by his means was put from it; for in deed he was a man that in all his doings seemed not to favour any kind of Popery, nor could not abide the snoffyng pride of some prelates, which undoubtedly, whatsoever else was the cause of his death, did shorten his life and procured the end that he was brought unto.” 

Recently I caught up with Teri Fitzgerald, researcher of the Cromwell family, to learn more about our Earl of Essex’s loved ones, namely those who “knew nothing but truth by him (that) both lamented him and heartily prayed for him”. Despite the known complexities of Thomas Cromwell, he was a man who was dearly loved. Let’s now meet those who mourned his loss.

________________________________

Teri, can you tell us about Thomas Cromwell’s wife and two sisters? Do we know anything about his mother?

His mother’s name was Meverell and she was the aunt of Nicholas Glossop of Wirksworth in Derbyshire; Thomas had two older sisters: Katherine, who married Welshman Morgan Williams, a brewer who came from a prominent family that had settled in Putney; and Elizabeth, who married a sheep farmer by the name of William Wellyfed. Katherine and Morgan Williams had died by the time Cromwell made his will in July 1529, leaving two sons, Richard and Walter. Elizabeth and her husband died early in 1533, leaving two children, Alice and Christopher (who taught his younger cousin Gregory to read).

________________________________

Joss Porter as Richard Cromwell
Credit: Wolf Hall, BBC

Thomas Cromwell’s nephew Richard took his last name after his father’s death and was close to Cromwell, working for his uncle through the years. My understanding is that Richard Cromwell, grandfather of Oliver Cromwell, was a favorite of King Henry VIII. What can you tell us about Richard Cromwell, his relationship with his uncle, and his relationship with the king?

Richard Cromwell (c.1510-1544) evidently regarded his uncle with esteem and affection and was the minister’s most trusted agent. Thanks largely to his exploits in the tiltyard, he came to be a favourite of Henry VIII. Richard had been appointed as a gentleman of the privy chamber by 1539, and was knighted by the king during a tournament at Westminster in May 1540 after he defeated two foreign knights. Early in 1534 he married Frances Murfyn (c.1519–c.1543), the daughter of Thomas Murfyn (a former lord mayor of London), and his second wife Elizabeth Donne. He took part in the king’s campaign in France in 1544 and died shortly after his return to England. He was survived by two sons, Henry, and Francis.

________________________________

This portrait by from the workshop of Hans Holbein was in the ownership of the Sadler family and is perhaps Ralph Sadler.

Ralph Sadler, ward of Thomas Cromwell, thrived professionally during the reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI and Elizabeth I. Can you give us a sense of who Ralph Sadler was like as a person, his giftedness, and his service to both Cromwell and then the crown?

Ralph Sadler’s wife, Ellen Barre (née Mitchell) was Cromwell’s cousin. Sadler was close to Cromwell and unflinchingly loyal, even if that loyalty put himself in danger. For example, it was Sadler who dared to give Cromwell’s letter pleading for mercy to the king. After Cromwell’s death, Sadler and his son, Thomas (Cromwell’s godson and namesake) kept a portrait of Cromwell in their possession. The portrait remained in the Sadler family until 1660. Sadler was an able and trusted servant to the Crown, esteemed as a soldier, diplomat and administrator.

________________________________

Athena Droutis (Grace Cromwell) with Mark Rylance (Thomas Cromwell) — BBC Wolf Hall

What do we know of Cromwell’s daughters Ann and Grace?

Other than their existence, very little: they were probably younger than Gregory and close in age given the sums set aside for their upkeep and marriage in Cromwell’s will.

Little known by many is the belief by historians that Thomas Cromwell had an illegitimate daughter named Jane. What do we know of her?

Cromwell had an illegitimate daughter named Jane, who was probably born around 1530/35. By 1550 Jane had married William Hough of Leighton in Cheshire, the son of Richard Hough and Christiana Calverley. William’s father acted as Cromwell’s agent in Cheshire, then in Ireland from 1535 to 1540. Jane and William came to the attention of the authorities as recusant Catholics during the reign of Elizabeth I. They were survived by a daughter, Alice who married William Whitmore. Their son, another William Whitmore married Margaret Beeston. Their daughter, Bridget married firstly Edward Somerset, the fifth son of the 4th earl of Worcester and after his death wed Thomas Savage, second son of Viscount Savage of Rocksavage. Bridget’s sister-in-law, Jane Savage, was the wife of John Paulet, 5th Marquess of Winchester, a descendant of Elizabeth Seymour’s third husband, John Paulet.

________________________________

This young man, age 24, painted by Hans Holbein the Younger, is thought by researcher Teri Fitzgerald to be Gregory Cromwell. To see her fascinating article, visit the Anne Boleyn Files HERE.

Gregory Cromwell — There are two schools of thought related to the son of the king’s most faithful servant. Was Gregory Cromwell an “under achiever” or younger than many historians believe?

Gregory Cromwell (c.1520-1551) was born earlier than has been supposed, as was his wife, Elizabeth (c.1518-1568). Early historians were mistaken in their assumption that Cromwell’s son was around fifteen when he was at Cambridge in 1529, when in fact he was “significantly younger than twelve”. In 1846 Sir Henry Ellis examined a letter written by Gregory to his father in around 1533 realising the handwriting was that of a boy in his early teens, born about 1520. The young man was provided with an education suitable for a nobleman and he used it to his advantage. He shared his father’s talent for accumulating property, and when he died, he was immensely wealthy.

________________________________

Tom Holland as Gregory Cromwell
Credit: Wolf Hall, BBC

It is amazing when you think of it that Gregory Cromwell was brother-in-law to queen consort Jane Seymour. How was the match between Gregory Cromwell and Elizabeth Cromwell arranged? Though a brokered arrangement, did Cromwell and Seymour grow to love each other?

The match may have been suggested to Thomas Cromwell by Edward Seymour, who had negotiated his sister’s first marriage to Sir Anthony Ughtred in 1531. Elizabeth Seymour was the second wife of Sir Anthony Ughtred and not his first. Gregory’s letter to his “loving bedfellow” from Calais hints at a harmonious union.

Editor’s Note: An excerpt from the letter Teri references is now provided:

“….I am, thanks be to God, in good health, trusting shortly to hear from you like news, as well of yourself as also my little boys, of whose increase and towardness be you assured I am not a little desirous to be advertised. And thus, not having any other news to write, I bid you most heartily well to fare. At Calais, the 9th of December. Your loving bedfellow, Gregory Cromwell.” 

________________________________

When Thomas Cromwell was imprisoned, he wrote to the king pleading for the safety of his family and those close to him. I find it fascinating that Gregory Cromwell, Elizabeth Seymour Cromwell, Richard Cromwell and Ralph Sadler survived and then soon later thrived during the remaining reign of King Henry VIII. How did they all manage this while those close to others who fell during Henry’s reign, such as Thomas More’s children, faded off into obscurity?

After Cromwell’s death, his family was all too aware that political ambition could prove deadly, and that in order to survive it was essential to be discreet, outwardly compliant and to loyal to the Crown. Their family connections probably contributed to their future prosperity.

________________________________

Thomas Cromwell
(Artist: Hans Holbein the Younger)

Thomas Cromwell — heretic, traitor or martyr?

He was certainly not a traitor, although his religious leanings and promotion of heretical books left him vulnerable to accusations of heresy. In 1540 Thomas Cromwell became the latest casualty in the ongoing struggle for influence over a capricious king. Cromwell was a visionary in a time of significant political, religious and social upheaval. He was a brilliant politician, and a man of deep religious convictions, who had the misfortune to be Henry VIII’s most faithful servant.

.

________________________________

Queen Jane Seymour
Artist: Hans Holbein the Younger

How did Gregory Cromwell and Elizabeth Seymour pull off surviving the death of Jane Seymour, and more amazing yet the executions of Thomas Cromwell, Thomas Seymour, and Edward Seymour? Just how remarkable was the resourcefulness of Elizabeth Seymour in particular in pulling off the improbable.

It was indeed remarkable that Gregory and his wife not only survived Thomas Cromwell’s fall from power but that of the Duke of Somerset as well.  Cromwell’s letter to the king from the Tower had moved the king, but it was not enough: it was evident that he feared for his family. Elizabeth’s letter to the king, with her connection to the late Queen Jane, may have saved them from ruin.

.

.

________________________________

Latimer preaches before Edward VI at St Paul’s Cross.

Did Gregory Cromwell and Elizabeth Seymour enjoy a relationship with their nephew King Edward VI? Three of their children were within 3 years of age of Edward. Is there any record of these children knowing Edward as either prince or king? Did they enjoy any meaningful relationship?

Whether or not Gregory, Elizabeth or their children had a relationship with their royal nephew is a mystery. Elizabeth’s brother-in-law certainly came to the young king’s attention. Clement Smith, a devout Catholic, who was married to her younger sister, Dorothy, earned a rebuke from the young king for attending mass once too often.

________________________________

This Regency Era engraving is labelled “Cromwell: Statesman”, from an original portrait, 1560. Is this Thomas or his brother Henry?

Are there any direct descendants of Gregory and Elizabeth Cromwell (and thus by extension Thomas Cromwell) that browsers would find of interest?

Henry Ughtred (c.1533-1598), a soldier and shipbuilder, was the son of Elizabeth Seymour and her first husband, Sir Anthony Ughtred. He married Elizabeth Paulet (c.1536-1576). In 1586 he left to seek his fortune in Ireland with his stepson Sir William Courtenay (1553-1630), and died in Munster during the Irish rebellion of 1598.

Thomas Cromwell (c.1540-c.1611), third son of Gregory Cromwell and Elizabeth Seymour. His diaries of proceedings in the House of Commons are an important source for historians of parliamentary history during the period when he was a member.

Edward Cromwell, 3rd Baron Cromwell (c.1560-1607), eldest son of Henry Cromwell, 2nd Baron Cromwell (1538-1592) and Mary Paulet (c.1540-1592), was involved in the Essex rebellion and survived due to the intercession of Robert Cecil. He was released after several months’ imprisonment and fined the staggering sum of £6,000. Already in debt, he was forced to sell off his lands and later settled in Ireland.

Katherine Cromwell (1565-1620), the only daughter of Henry Cromwell, 2nd Baron Cromwell (1538-1592) and Mary Paulet (c.1540-1592), married Lionel Tollemache (1562-1612). Their descendants were the wealthy earls of Dysart who were related by marriage to several prominent noble families.

Lady Ann Strode was murdered at Parnham House, near Beaminster, Dorset in 1645 by a soldier under the command of Colonel Thomas Fairfax. Lady Ann was the widow of Sir John Strode (c.1561-1642), son of John Strode (d.1581) by his first wife Katherine (c. 1541), elder daughter of Gregory Cromwell and Elizabeth Seymour.

________________________________

Though often identified as Catherine Howard, scholars now believe this Holbein is actually Elizabeth Seymour.

I understand that you find the life of Elizabeth Seymour Cromwell fascinating. What can you tell us about Lady Cromwell that browsers may find admirable and/or interesting?

It is remarkable that Elizabeth Seymour has practically disappeared from the history of the period. She has been described as “only a knight’s daughter, the widow of a knight, and the wife of a gentleman”, however, like Mary Howard, the Duchess of Richmond, she was a member of the royal family. Following her sister, Jane’s marriage to the king and the subsequent birth of an heir, Elizabeth was the king’s sister-in-law, and aunt to the future Edward VI. Elizabeth was the daughter-in-law of the most powerful man in England, next to the king, and a worthy subject for a portrait by Hans Holbein.

.

________________________________

ABOUT TODAY’S GUEST

Teri Fitzgerald
(Portrait of a woman called Princess Mary, Duchess of Suffolk –
Elizabeth Seymour? – 1844, William Essex.)

Born in Sydney, Australia, Teri Fitzgerald is a retired systems analyst with a passion for history. Well acquainted with the Tudor court from an early age, Teri is presently researching the work of Hans Holbein and the Cromwell family. In 2016 her article on Gregory Cromwell, co-written with Diarmaid MacCulloch, was published in The Journal of Ecclesiastical History.

Teri Fitzgerald and DIARMAID MacCulloch (2016). Gregory Cromwell: Two Portrait Miniatures by Hans Holbein the Younger. The Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 67, pp 587-601 

Beth von Staats

is the owner and administrator of QueenAnneBoleyn.com. The author of "Thomas Cranmer in a Nutshell", Beth specializes in writing magazine articles, online historical articles, short stories, and flash fiction.

Leave a Reply